Is your cat a picky eater? Have you experienced them avoiding their food and pushing their food bowls around? We can relate!

Though if they’re doing any of these things, it may very well be an indication that you need to change your cat food – ASAP! 

In this post, we will help you find the most amazing all-natural cat food out there. The best part about this is that all of these cat foods are available on the internet so you can have everything delivered straight to your doorstep.

Because cats are such finicky eaters, you may have to try a few different food before you find one your cat loves. The list below will give you a number of excellent All-Natural cat foods to test with your finicky feline.

Key Features To Look For When Buying Cat Food

  • Quality of the product
  • Ingredients used in making the cat food
  • Health benefits it can bring your cat
  • Pricing 

Our Top Picks For All Natural Cat Food

Overall Top Pick: Sheba Perfect Portions Pate Wet Cat Food Trays

The Sheba Perfect Portions Pate Wet Cat Food Trays is one of the best cat food out there. It offers plenty of flavors to give your cat a lot of options. It is made with premium quality ingredients, real protein, essential vitamins and minerals for cat maintenance and kitten growth. 

It is also convenient for you, as all you have to do is open the pack and serve! Yes, it is a little bit on the expensive side, but it is our overall top pick because of the following reasons:

Key Features

  • Contains twenty-four (24) 2.6 oz. twin pack trays (48 servings total) 
  • Delectable patés made without grain – no corn, soy, or wheat
  • Freshness at every meal with no messy leftovers: just snap, peel, and serve to your adult cat
  • Helps support the overall health and vitality of your feline friend – so the purrs never end

What Others Are Saying About This Sheba Perfect Portions Pate Wet Cat Food Trays

“My senior cat has gone through a lifetime of preferences by now, but most of her life she ate dry kibble. As she matured, she began to have thyroid issues and simply could not eat enough. She’d overeat, then vomit it all up. So I decided to try different types of wet food to alternate her dry food with. We tried all the “good” natural brands, as well as the cheaper lower quality brands in search of something she would eat for more than 1 or 2 cans. We tried grills, pates, chunks, and gravies. Nothing was working and she was losing weight pretty quickly. I decided to try Sheba with her after reading some reviews here. So glad I did. Every meal is fresh. She eats 3-4 portions per day, and a 3am portion of dry kibble. She absolutely loves this stuff, and has even gained a little weight back. If you are having problems with your cat finding the “right” food, I’d definitely recommend your cat try this stuff.”

“I have an elderly 16 year old cat that has been slowly losing her teeth – one by one. She has been through several tooth extractions to halt infections and dental disease over the past 2 years. During this time, she’s lost her palate for a variety of foods. She’s completely done with dry kibble and now refuses the conventional “canned” food. I had been using “pate'” formulas of canned food but she’s turned her nose up to even these more recently. When she started losing weight I got desperate and on a hunch – or should I say hope – I picked up a couple of these perfect portions of Sheba pate’ and wow, wow, WOW!!! She ate 5 in a row – making up for lost nutrition! I am relieved to see that her body weight has returned to normal and she is well hydrated…a Happy Senior Cat. She normally eats 3 perfect portion cups a day now – sometimes 4. Thank you so much Sheba!”

“I’ve searched for nearly a year for a wet cat food for my kitty who has stomatitis. Poor guy has lost all of his teeth, and the vet said to feed him only wet foods to lessen his chance for pain. He was on Fancy Feast for gravy lovers, then FF pate. I don’t know if he tired of this brand, but it looked as though he was eating less and less. I used broths and stews and bisque, but these were geared toward snacks, not meals. I recently purchased the SHEBA pate, and he’s starting to get his appetite back again. I’ve tried about 4 pate’ brands, this one is the absolute softest. It is soft enough and “fluffy” enough not to get plastered into the bowl as he licks it up. This is truly a lifesaving game changer for my little guy. He’s about 10, and with the stomatitis, he needs all the help he can get. SHEBA pate’ will help me to keep him as healthy as possible. Thank you SHEBA folks!”

Customer’s Top Pick: Blue Buffalo Healthy Aging Natural Mature Dry Cat Food

The Healthy Aging Natural Mature Dry Cat Food from Blue Buffalo is our customer’s top pick for the day. It is perfect for senior cats and promotes healthy aging at this stage in their life. 

This cat food is made from all-natural, premium ingredients with LifeSource bits. It provides healthy nutrients for senior cats so they can enjoy their senior years!

Key Features

  • Delicious, protein-rich, deboned chicken
  • Wholesome whole grains and veggies
  • NO chicken (or poultry) by-products
  • Blue for Cats is made with ingredients chosen with great care by our animal nutritionists, providing your mature cat with the right balance of high-quality protein and complex carbohydrates

What Others Are Saying About Healthy Aging Natural Mature Dry Cat Food from Blue Buffalo

“My cats are very fussy – aren’t most cats – and were quite content with their cat crunchies. However, with aging comes kidney concerns etc., and I cringed at having to switch their food to lower protein/ash. Surprise, surprise!! The went for BLUE Mature Healthy Aging Chicken & Brown…. by Blue Buffalo the very first day, and come looking for more. What a kitty compliment for this Healthy Aging formula!”

“We’ve got a 16 year old Russian Blue who has retired from hunting. Her old cat food tended to induce vomiting more often than not (not a good way to stay healthy). Once we switched her over to this, her coat stays shiny and she does not vomit her food anymore. Thats a win for us and her.”

“My cats absolute fav food. We noticed allot of positive changes in our indoor cat after staring her on this food. She is happier, sheds less,sleeps better, doesn’t vomit daily (or hardly at all) and other small good things too. This product has been great for her and has been worth every penny of the extra cost when you compare it to crap food at the supermarket tha will eventually cost us vet bills in the end more than likely! Thanks for helping our kitty have a better life Blue!”

Best Cat Food For All Ages: Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dry Cat Food, Grain-Free

The Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dry Cat Food, Grain Free is perfect for cats of every age. It is made from premium-quality ingredients without grains!

The main ingredient used is real salmon and green peas to promote great health. It also features feline probiotics to help aid in their digestive health.

Key Features

  • Grain-free cat food
  • Made with high-quality salmon
  • Limited ingredient diets help minimize the number of ingredients cats are exposed to
  • Complete, balances nutrition for all cats

What Others Are Saying About Natural Balance L.I.D. Limited Ingredient Diets Dry Cat Food, Grain Free

“This food has made my “children” healthy and happy. One of my cats had a food allergy so bad that she would scratch cuts into her face and neck. The other used to vomit up her food every day and have a rough coat. I had tried all the store brand cat foods to try and help them. My vet recommended this food, since then there are no allergic reactions or vomiting, and both of them have shiny silky coats!”

“This product saved my sweet girl from a horrible food allergy. She is 11 and was licking and biting all her fur off of her. The vet recommended an expensive brand, but I read great reviews on the internet of the green pea and duck dry cat food and decided to give it a try. Within 1 week she was itching and licking less and could finally relax. She never had a food allergy this bad and I am so thankful for this product. She used to also vomit up her food and I thought it was due to eating too fast, but now I’ve learned it was due to her allergy and sensitive stomach. This has now subsided too after a couple weeks of eating this product.”

“We have been using this food for five years now and have no plans on changing. One of our cats was diagnosed with food allergies after we took him in for self-inflicted scratches on his face. The vet wanted us to buy the expensive prescription food. We leave food out all of the time and let our cats eat whenever they are hungry, so this was not an ideal or cost effective solution in a multi-cat household. Luckily, the L.I.D. green pea and salmon formula worked for us and we did not have to make this switch.”

Other Top Picks

Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein Grain Free, Natural Kitten Dry Cat Food, Chicken 5-Lb

The Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein Grain Free, Natural Kitten Dry Cat Food is a chicken-flavored cat food that is protein-filled and doesn’t contain grains! It also features great amino acids to support brain and eye development, balanced protein and carbs for a healthier, more balanced diet. 

Key Features

  • Delicious, protein-rich, deboned chicken
  • Sweet potatoes that provide healthy complex carbohydrates
  • Cranberries, blueberries, and carrots that support antioxidant enrichment
  • NO grains or glutens
  • NO chicken (or poultry) by-products

What Others Are Saying About Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein Grain Free

“If you love your kitties… and my wife does (I guess, I do too), it’s a must. Our hellions are about 7 months old, and are not only more energetic, but have great muscle tone, and even seem to be more intelligent/responsive to us, than cats we have had in the past… The wife has apparently done research and has ensured me that not only are we not feeding our cats other cats… but, this is the: “Trader-Joe’s”/ “Whole Foods”/ “gluten-free”… vegan… kosher… blah blah blah… etc. etc., of cat food. To be honest, it actually smells pretty good. Good enough, I’ve considered having a taste compared to some of the stuff that comes home from Trader Joe’s… But, the cats AND wife are happy so, can’t complain!”

“I have two 5-6 month old once feral kittens. This is one of the first foods I bought them. The bigger one ripped open the bag. He loves the crinkle of this plastic. I’m not sure which came first, the love of shredding all plastic things, or this food. But they seem to like this food. They are healthy cats, so I think this is supporting their development. I’ve tried one other kind of kibble, and they seem to prefer this over the other brand. The only negative thing I can think of about this product is that at the bottom of each bag there is about a quarter cup of powder from the kibble breaking down. Not unusual, and maybe just a sign of this being a less “mealy” product that is easier for them to crunch up and digest.”

“We have two kittens and a 2-yo cat (all rescues) who all eat this. We tried putting the adult on adult food, but the kittens gravitated to that and the adult to the kitten food. The adult *needed* to eat more and the kittens were overeating, so I decided to just feed the kitten food to all of them for the time being. It has worked out well; the kittens are developing nicely without gaining too much weight and the 2-yo has filled out to a nice, healthy weight (still slim, but not too skinny, as she was). All seem healthy (energetic, bright eyes, smooth coats, solid BM’s…), happy and playful. Will continue with this until it’s time to move to the adult food.”

Better in the Raw for Cats – Make your own homemade RAW cat food!

This incredible cat food, Better in the Raw, is made to help provide your kitty with essential nutrients and protein for maximum health and longevity.  No grains used, and instructions are included in the package. 

Key Features

  • Homemade Raw Cat Food – Better in the Raw for Cats is a premix for preparing a raw meat diet for cats
  • This diet is ideal for all life stages and is made with 100% human-grade ingredients.
  • Grain-free & easy to use, just add meat and water.
  • Trial size will make 6lbs. of finished food (24 – 1/2 cup servings – enough for one adult cat for approx. 3 weeks)

What Others Are Saying About Better in the Raw

“I was making my raw cat food when my meat grinder just stopped. Apparently I wasn’t supposed to grind bone. Lol. Is I got this supplement to replace the calcium lost from no bone. I like this supplement better than another brand I got and the cats like it to. If you find this review helpful please like. Thanks”

“My cat was recently diagnosed with diabetes. She is a 14 year old fire point Siames, she had started to go down hill rapidly, our veterinarian suggested a change in diet to raw foods and after quite a bit of research I decided to use this product mixed with raw meats. After a month she is vastly improved! From being able to hardly walk she is now jumping and even playing again! Her coat is silky and her mood is so much better she howls for her food and bats at my hand to put it down for her when it is time to eat she absolutely loves it and I love the results, I would recommend this to any cat owner for my cat it was quite literally a life saver.”

“Easy to use. I like knowing that I’m feeding my cat a complete and healthy diet. My cat likes it too. After a $2500 vet bill from feeding him Rachel Rays cat food (bacterial infection) I will never buy packaged food again. I buy good lean meat, and freeze enough for two weeks at a time. I am very happy with this product. Happy, healthy, playful cat that sheds way less. My cat is a rescue from the Humane Society.”

Leave a Reply